Why Everyone Keeps Pronouncing Cacio E Pepe Wrong: the Roman Secret

Exploring the core elements of Why Everyone Keeps Pronouncing Cacio E Pepe Wrong: the Roman Secret—check out what experts are saying.

Q1: What does "cacio" mean, and how is it different from "formaggio"?
A1: Both words mean cheese. "Formaggio" is standard Italian used throughout the entire country for any style of cheese. "Cacio" is a traditional central and southern Italian word rooted in Latin (*caseus*) that specifically denotes regional sheep's milk cheeses, such as Pecorino Romano.

Q2: Why isn't the "i" in "cacio" pronounced?
A2: In Italian spelling rules, the letter "i" functions as a diacritic after the letter "c" when followed by vowels like "a", "o", or "u". It indicates that the "c" should be pronounced softly as "ch" ([tʃ]) rather than hard like "k". The "i" itself remains silent.

Q3: Can I substitute Parmesan cheese in authentic cacio e pepe?
A3: Traditional Roman recipes call exclusively for aged Pecorino Romano DOP. Parmigiano Reggiano is made from cow's milk and has a sweeter, nuttier flavor profile, whereas Pecorino Romano is sheep's milk cheese with a sharper, saltier punch necessary to balance the cracked pepper. Some modern chefs use a 70/30 blend of Pecorino and Parmigiano to soften the saltiness, but purists stick strictly to Pecorino.

Q4: Why does my cacio e pepe sauce turn into clumps when I cook it at home?
A4: Clumping occurs when the cooking water added to the grated cheese is too hot, causing the proteins in the Pecorino to seize and separate from the fats. To ensure a smooth emulsion, mix the finely grated cheese with warm (not boiling) pasta water in a separate bowl off the heat until it forms a thick paste, then toss it with the cooked pasta once the pan has cooled slightly below 65°C.