Is 'The O. C.' Really Coming Back? Mischa Barton Teases Reunion and Shocking Casting Secrets
Every iconic television show is built on a pile of alternate realities. Casting director Patrick Rush and creator Josh Schwartz have candidly discussed how close the production came to an entirely different ensemble. Garrett Hedlund read extensively for Ryan Atwood before securing feature film work. Chad Michael Murray was pursued aggressively by network executives before committing to One Tree Hill. McKenzie won the role mere days before cameras rolled, bringing an understated working-class intensity that grounded what could have been disposable soap opera fluff.
Seth Cohen's casting proved even more contentious. Schwartz initially disliked Brody's audition because the actor improvised without bothering to memorize the sides. Schwartz asked Rush never to bring him back. When casting agents failed to find anyone who could capture the self-deprecating cadence of the comic-book-obsessed outcast, Brody was brought back. His second read secured the job instantly. Olivia Wilde famously auditioned for Marissa Cooper. The creative team found her charismatic presence too formidable for the fragile vulnerability required for Marissa. Wilde was later brought in as Alex Kelly during season two.