Is Crave Really a Crumbl Copycat? Debunking Utah Cookie War Myths
By Alexander Ross
The timeline of this rivalry highlights how a regional squabble over cardboard shapes transformed into a nationwide retail conflict. While social media discussions peaked in late 2022, the commercial mechanics unfolded methodically over several years.
| Timeframe | Legal & Operational Development | Market Consequence |
|---|---|---|
| 2017, 2019 | Crumbl pioneers the viral weekly rotation; Crave launches deep dish baking operations in Utah. | Gourmet cookie category experiences triple-digit customer adoption across the Intermountain West. |
| 2022 | Crumbl files Lanham Act trade dress lawsuits against Crave and Dirty Dough in Utah Federal Court. | Social channels flood with #UtahCookieWars; Dirty Dough launches parody billboards while Crave defends its trade dress. |
| 2023, 2024 | Litigants enter protracted discovery; confidential settlement agreements quiet formal courtroom friction. | Competitors adjust peripheral branding details while retaining their core baking processes and menus. |
| 2025, 2026 | Crave establishes multi-state franchise footprint, launching its high-profile Central Texas expansion. | Direct retail competition replaces legal combat as regional chains vie for corporate-tier strip mall leases. |
The litigation eventually settled behind closed doors, a standard resolution for trade dress disputes where neither party benefits from protracted public disclosure. Crave adjusted elements of its presentation to build clear brand space, but the fundamental structure of its commercial offering remained intact.
Alexander Ross has covered the video game industry for a decade, writing deep dives on game design, esports tournaments, VR developments, and gaming culture.
Tags:
crave vs crumbl
