A Timeline of the Night: Inside the Lizzie Borden Stepmother Murder Investigation
Q1: Was Abby Borden asleep in bed when she was murdered?
No. Forensic pathology and blood-spatter patterns established that Abby was standing upright when attacked. She was changing pillow shams on the guest bed, faced her attacker, and collapsed into the narrow space between the bed and the dressing bureau.
Q2: Why did people believe the stepmother was sleeping?
Early reports in August 1892 misconstrued initial police statements describing Abby lying beside the bed. Sensational newspapers conflated Andrew Borden’s death, who was indeed asleep on the sitting room couch, with Abby’s demise upstairs.
Q3: Can visitors stay overnight in the room where Abby Borden died?
Yes. The Lizzie Borden House operates as a bed-and-breakfast and museum. Guests can book the second-floor John V. Morse bedroom, sleeping on the exact spot where Abby Borden was murdered in 1892.